Home | Top 10 | List | Latest | Suggest | News | Login
| vs |
| Gandalf | Elminster |
|---|---|
| Magic A large Beard A bossy Attitude |
Magic A large Beard A Bossy Attitude |
| 6226 Votes | 1248 Votes |
| Comments | |
|---|---|
|
13 13 Qwerty 2006-May-05 15:14 |
well thank you for the information |
|
Steelbeard 2006-May-10 09:08 |
WTF? |
|
Steelbeard 2006-May-10 09:08 |
Is this a fight at all?? |
|
13 13 Qwerty 2006-May-11 11:39 |
Not really... |
|
cornholio123_62 2006-May-13 13:59 |
hi |
|
Scythe 2006-May-16 20:53 |
hi to you cornholio123_62 |
|
Catalyst 2006-Jun-05 20:22 |
I say equally matched |
|
13 13 Qwerty 2006-Jun-06 01:03 |
You say so, it is not. |
|
yodaisgod 2006-Jun-20 09:41 |
yeah, Gandalf kicks his arse |
|
Dark Knight 2006-Jun-27 02:15 |
wtf! |
|
yodaisgod 2006-Jun-28 15:02 |
Gandalf easy |
|
13 13 Qwerty 2006-Jul-03 03:07 |
of course |
|
Sgt.DeathTouch 2006-Jul-26 11:28 |
gandalf |
|
I don't Care 2006-Oct-06 22:02 |
Death to Elminster |
|
mr. johnson 2007-Feb-10 12:29 |
gandalf |
|
Grael409 2007-Feb-21 20:53 |
Gandalf pwns ninjas |
|
Pec 2007-Feb-23 18:57 |
Elminster can't be killed by magic. That's like his whole deal. He also occaisonally whups gods, so the whole gandalf is a god arguement doesn't hold much water. |
|
SilentSlayer771 2007-Apr-12 15:44 |
Gandalf rapes if he dies he just becomes more powerful and comes back to own u again and again... so i think elminister might beat the grey but white would kick his ASS |
|
captainpancreas 2007-Apr-19 16:46 |
Gandalf pawns Elminster...whoever that is. |
|
darkblorg 2007-Apr-30 11:13 |
GANDALFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF.... bla |
|
Obi-Wonton 2007-May-15 16:34 |
I think pec is right.... the Elminster is kinda the most powerfull being of all time.... but Gandalf still owns |
|
Legacy of Phunk 2007-May-21 06:42 |
Gandalf doesn't hit with just pure force all the time, he tends to use the things around him to bring down the house. Plus Gandalf demolished a Balrog, for the most part, single handed. |
|
incognitogoddess 2007-May-31 22:29 |
Come on, Gandalf ascended to White! He's a summation of all the color which represent different magics! Withouth becoming evil like Sauroman of Many Colors (did I spell that right) :P |
|
chub chub 2007-Jun-30 19:29 |
gandalf turns into gandalf the white plus he has a sword |
|
spartan001 2007-Jul-27 04:17 |
GANDALF RULES!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
|
OlasDchampion 2007-Aug-01 02:57 |
Um.... whos Elministar |
|
Dyson_48 2007-Aug-01 20:14 |
All i can say if you have read any of the forgotten realms novels you would know that elminster is incredibly more powerfull than gandolf. Gandolf barely even cast any spells WOW gandolf beat a balrog, elminster went to hell and beat hundreds of demons. |
|
rhathar 2007-Aug-21 19:05 |
Gandalf can't die, though. He's a Maia and part of those beings that created the universe. And none of them EVER die, they just go chill with Iluvatar if they get banished (happened... once) |
|
BloodDuster 2007-Sep-10 02:54 |
Gandalf is a little bitch, Eliminster would pwn him up nicely |
|
Holmanmad 2007-Sep-12 10:34 |
Gandalf the white easy |
|
Liverpool 2007-Sep-19 17:14 |
Gandalf will do the chuck norrios!Kicks Eliminster in the balls! |
|
Clintone 2007-Sep-26 11:43 |
Who's Eliminister? |
|
Godzilla65 2007-Oct-12 16:23 |
there iz such a big difference in them(not) |
|
blackheartz 2007-Oct-16 09:51 |
well because of different way that magic works in the lotr nad in FR elminster is more powerfull cause on spell is enough to sent gandalf chill with illuvatar for the rest of the eternity |
|
blackheartz 2007-Oct-16 09:55 |
even if gandalf came in his true maia form i dont think he could defeat elminster for the same reason as above the mechanics of magic work differently in the 2 worlds and elminster has the upper hand |
|
artemis7227 2007-Oct-23 14:58 |
well u kno what blackheartz? fuck u. and gandalf wins all the way. elminster can go back to hell for all i care. |
|
blackheartz 2007-Oct-23 19:37 |
artemis u suck u just say thinks without backing them up so shut up and die in agony bitch |
|
The power behind 2007-Oct-29 06:08 |
I think most of you dont know Elmister as well. Forgotten Realms is a Power Gaming World, here is nearly everyone a superhero. If i take them all seriously the would pawn the whole universe including Chuck Norris, Godzilla, Sauron, Gandalf (in any form). |
|
The power behind 2007-Oct-29 06:10 |
Darth Vader, Superman, Luke, Obi-wan, Aragorn, the Master Chief, Alucard, .... Yes. In my opinion it is unfair to compare a charakter (mainly a wizard or sorcerer) from FR with anyone else. |
|
x8888 2007-Nov-15 19:51 |
where's the video? |
|
Mr.Doobie6 2007-Nov-26 17:05 |
Gandalf's book was better. Enough said. |
|
Clintone 2007-Dec-09 14:57 |
If Gandalf passed away and became Gandalf the White, next time would he become Gandalf the Clear? |
|
tv4fun 2007-Dec-12 17:48 |
OVER 4000 VOTES DON'T THINK I CAN PUT UP MY PEACE POST |
|
tv4fun 2007-Dec-12 17:48 |
but I will any way |
|
tv4fun 2007-Dec-12 17:48 |
oh yeah, can every one just stop fighting for one measly day |
|
Mechagodzilla67 2007-Dec-16 14:05 |
Gandalf would dominate. |
|
Thekingofallbums 2007-Dec-24 17:57 |
Omg people don't know who Elminster of shadowdale is?!? |
|
doomknight69 2007-Dec-27 14:53 |
Wow this would be a sad match. Gandalf would die so fast it would leave you bored. |
|
Death Strika__ 2008-Jan-07 02:04 |
WOW doomnight and all u fuckshits who voted for elminster Gandalf is Maia and is a GOD in valinor u dumbasses and by the way unless your dick is to tiny to notice, Elminster would suck ur cocks for protection |
|
blackheartz 2008-Jan-09 08:21 |
gandalf doesnt stand a chance even in his true maia form because due to the different mechanics of the 2 worlds elminster has a huge arsenal of epic spells at his command, he can send gandalf back to illuvatar for the rest of eternity with a single spell |
|
Black_Melchid 2008-Jan-12 08:17 |
Elminster wins! Just taoal immunity and incarcerate or some nasty lvl. 10 Wizard tricks, and Gandalf=smelly fudge. |
|
DeathArtist 2008-Jan-14 22:11 |
demiGOD vs umm what's his face |
|
awk11 2008-Feb-22 22:04 |
gandolf the gray or gandolf the white. |
|
Zahr Dalsk 2008-Feb-28 01:15 |
Gandalf, on account of Elminster being a big pushover and Gandalf being a walking god. |
|
Valkeira 2008-Mar-04 19:58 |
I think Elminister being unknown- everyone's just gonna state that Gandalf is just going to run him over. But Elminister kicks fucking ass. You don't see like 5+ books about Gandalf. LotR is about some ring. Imo Elminister would ape the shit out of Sauron |
|
Maethoriel 2008-Apr-14 01:53 |
LotR is not just about some ring. And Gandalf would definitely win. Not even close. |
|
bladannybla007 2008-May-06 18:23 |
gandalf wins, he is a GOD, he created the universe, wears a ring of power, commands an ARMY from time to time, has the fastest horse ever and HE CAN'T DIE!!enouf said |
|
bladannybla007 2008-May-06 18:24 |
o and he killed a balrog |
|
bladannybla007 2008-May-06 18:30 |
if u didn't know balrogs are the most powerful demon, more powerful than 100 normal ones |
|
Danuthal 2008-May-17 11:20 |
The only reason Gandalf gets so many votes is because NO ONE READS. Elminster, who has the powers of a god, who has held the very fabric of the universe together with sheer will, who is immune to magic, would demolish Gandalf. |
|
Eckister 2008-May-28 10:15 |
point one-elminster can stop time... point two-elminster is a favourite of the goddess of magic... point three-gandalf killed one demon, elminster killed dozens... |
|
Eckister 2008-May-28 10:16 |
due to these reasons he would win... gandalf would return you say? well, just in case he wouldnt get banished or have his soul torn out by elminster... yup sunnys, thats what elminster can do... |
|
teh_master_chief 2008-Jun-07 14:22 |
In lore, Gandalf and all the other Maiar are significantly more powerful than their movie-counterparts. Gandalf is pretty much a god -- his powers eclipse that of Elminster's. Gandalf is also the original, so he wins. |
|
Lhor 2008-Jun-09 07:30 |
elminster forbid gandalf to cast spells, than kill him with a thought. |
|
Lhor 2008-Jun-09 07:31 |
Elminster is just one step under the god of magic and killed hundreds of thousands demons WITHOUT magic while he pass the hell. Gandalf kills one (the guy with the sword and the whip) with all his power and died. |
|
Malvagita 2008-Jun-16 17:07 |
Im a big Lord of the Rings fan but I have to agree that if more people read the Forgotten Realms novels Elminster would be winning in votes |
|
dubs 2008-Jun-27 15:33 |
ummm, elminster can suck a dick |
|
RJman 2008-Jul-01 21:34 |
I agree wiith dubs |
|
wolfmancub 2008-Jul-05 03:59 |
I would say Gandolf because I have no idea who elimister is. Also a better fight involving magick would be gandolf and profeser snipe I think that's the guy the guy in harry potter the guy who makes the potions and is first enemies with harry potter |
|
wolfmancub 2008-Jul-05 04:02 |
Also a good supernatural fight would be michael Corvin off of underworld against dracula |
|
Zeroaster 2008-Aug-12 20:34 |
Gandalf can make stuff glow and swing a sword. Elminster can hurl fireballs the size of a castle and swing a sword. |
supported by PaperAirplanes
